At Misfits Market, we’re on a mission to make organic grocery delivery more exciting, more accessible, and more sustainable. One of the ways we do that? With our mystery produce bundles—a creative (and fun!) solution that helps farmers use more of their total harvest, while giving you delicious surprises with every box.
These variety-flexible offerings are a win-win: farmers get flexibility, food gets saved from waste, and customers get flavorful, seasonal organic produce delivered to their door from one of the best online grocery stores in the market.
Whether you’re shopping from your favorite organic food store or looking for a new way to discover fresh, flavorful ingredients, our organic grocery products are thoughtfully curated to help reduce food waste while elevating your meals.
What Are Mystery Produce Bundles?
These bundles change week to week based on what’s freshest and most abundant. By offering this kind of flexibility, we support small farms and sustainable growing practices—helping ensure more of their crops make it to homes like yours.
Our current mystery organic produce bundles include:
- 🧅 Organic Mystery Spring Alliums: spring red onions, garlic, shallots, or white onions
- 🥕 Organic Mystery Bunched Carrots: orange, purple, rainbow, or Nantes
- 🍆 Organic Mystery Small Eggplant: color, shape, or variety may vary
- 🍄 Organic Mystery Mushroom Sampler: Oyster, Shiitake, Lion’s Mane, Trumpet, Maitake, or a blend of ’em all
- 🌈 Organic Mystery Swiss Chard: color may vary
These bundles aren’t just a fun surprise—they’re one of the biggest reasons to buy organic through Misfits Market. By choosing produce that would otherwise be tilled under or left behind, you’re helping build a more resilient and thoughtful organic produce market.
What to Cook with Mystery Produce Bundles
Utilize the mystery produce in any of these organic recipes:
- Roasted Miso Butter Onions
- Roasted Carrots with Carrot Top Chimichurri
- Pasta with Silkiest Eggplant Sauce
- Curry Fried Oyster Mushrooms
- Spicy Mushroom Bulgogi Fried Rice
- Quick-Pickled Rainbow Swiss Chard Stems
Why the Mystery Matters
We work directly with organic farmers and suppliers to identify crops at risk of going to waste. Unlike traditional retailers that often require specific sizing or consistent varieties, we keep things flexible so we can accept the freshest product possible. In return, you get top-quality, in-season organic produce from a reliable organic grocery delivery partner.
When you shop at Misfits Market, you’re not only accessing some of the best organic grocery stores online, but also helping drive demand for more sustainable farming practices. Our organic food produce selection evolves with the seasons—and when you opt into a mystery item, you become part of the solution.
Why Farmers Have Extra
When we say “inconsistent demand” in relation to our mystery produce bundles, we’re referring to the unpredictable nature of how certain fruits and vegetables sell—especially with more niche or seasonal items. Traditional grocery retailers often avoid this kind of variability, which can lead to perfectly good produce being left behind.
Here’s what that really means:
- Not always a top seller: Some produce—like spring onions, rainbow carrots, or unique mushroom varieties—might not have steady or predictable demand from week to week, even though they’re high-quality and delicious.
- Weather and seasonality: A sudden shift in temperature can create a short window where crops are abundant—but they have to be sold quickly before they spoil or bolt in the field.
- Retail limitations: Other grocery stores may only accept a certain size, color, or quantity, leaving farmers with extra product that doesn’t meet strict retail specs—but is still perfectly tasty and fresh.
Our mystery bundles help solve this by giving farmers flexibility. Instead of matching a rigid retail order, they can harvest and ship what’s freshest. That’s a win for the farmer, for us (we prevent food waste!), and for the customer—who gets peak-season produce at a great price with a little surprise built in.
What Can You Expect?
Each mystery variety contains premium produce that’s been harvested at peak freshness—just without the traditional predictability. You might open your box to find a juicy bunch of rainbow carrots one week, or a trio of garlic bulbs the next. Whatever you get, it’s always high quality and ready to be part of your next great meal.
Plus, it’s a great way to try new things! Not sure what to do with a shallot? We’ve got recipes. Never cooked with purple carrots before? We’ll show you how. Check out recipe hub for tips on turning these organic grocery surprises into meals you love.
Ready to Join the Fun?
Browse our organic grocery store delivery options now—including all of our latest mystery produce items—and enjoy the unexpected while helping support farmers and reduce food waste.
