Mystery produce bundles are an easy way for you to try an assortment of fruits & vegetables, oftentimes including rare and hard-to-find varieties that may not be available in your local grocery store.
At Misfits Market, we’re on a mission to make organic grocery delivery more exciting, accessible, and sustainable. These bundles are one way we’re able to achieve this goal. By partnering directly with farmers, we can help you discover delicious new favorites while supporting small farms and sustainable growing practices.
Our groceries are thoughtfully curated to help reduce food waste, while helping you discover new favorites and elevating your meals. These bundles make the most of seasonal harvests, saving farm fresh fruits and vegetables that may have gone to waste for a number of reasons:
- Retail limitations, such as standardized sizing, aren’t a restriction for mystery bundles. This allows farmers to ship the freshest organic harvests as soon as they’re ready!
- Unpredictable weather impacts growing seasons, often leading to too little or too many of a crop for traditional grocery store demand.
- Unique varieties and colors of produce that are not well known, are less requested by traditional retailers. Mystery bundles are a great way for you to enjoy these less common types of fresh farm produce.
By trying mystery produce, you get to taste new fruits and veggies. Plus, you become part of the solution for a more sustainable food system.
It’s a win-win! Farmers get more flexibility, food gets rescued from needless waste, and you get farm fresh delivered straight to your door.
What Is Included In Mystery Produce Bundles?
Our produce bundles evolve with the seasons, changing from week to week based on what’s freshest and most abundant at our partner farms.
Currently, our mystery produce bundles include:
- 🧅 Organic Mystery Spring Alliums: spring red onions, garlic, shallots, or white onions
- 🥕 Organic Mystery Bunched Carrots: orange, purple, rainbow, or Nantes
- 🍆 Organic Mystery Small Eggplant: color, shape, or variety may vary
- 🍄 Organic Mystery Mushroom Sampler: Oyster, Shiitake, Lion’s Mane, Trumpet, Maitake, or a blend of ’em all
- 🌈 Organic Mystery Swiss Chard: color may vary
- 🌶️ Organic Mystery Hot Pepper Mix: Serranos, jalapeños, and cherry bomb peppers, or a mix of all three
- 🍑 Season’s Best Mystery Plumcot: From our friends at Family Tree Farms, this rotating pick is all about peak-season perfection. Each week, we bring you their juiciest, most flavorful plumcot variety—whichever one is eating best right now.
These bundles aren’t just a fun surprise—they’re one of the biggest reasons to buy farm fresh produce through Misfits Market. We work directly with organic farmers and suppliers to identify crops at risk of going to waste.
By choosing produce that would ultimately be tilled under or left behind, you’re helping build a more resilient and thoughtful food system. In return, you get top-quality, in-season organic produce from a reliable source.
What to Cook with Farm Fresh Produce
You can use fresh produce from our mystery bundles in any of these recipes:
- Roasted Miso Butter Onions
- Roasted Carrots with Carrot Top Chimichurri
- Pasta with Silkiest Eggplant Sauce
- Curry Fried Oyster Mushrooms
- Spicy Mushroom Bulgogi Fried Rice
- Quick-Pickled Rainbow Swiss Chard Stems
How Do Mystery Bundles Benefit Farmers?
When we say “inconsistent demand” in relation to organic produce, we’re referring to the unpredictable nature of how certain fruits and vegetables sell—especially with more niche or seasonal items.
Traditional grocery retailers often avoid this kind of variability, which can lead to perfectly good, fresh farm produce being left behind.
Here’s what causes those inconsistencies:
- Not always a top seller: Some produce—like spring onions, rainbow carrots, or unique mushroom varieties—might not have steady or predictable demand from week to week, even though they’re high-quality and delicious.
- Weather and seasonality: A sudden shift in temperature can create a short window where crops are abundant—but they have to be sold quickly before they spoil or bolt in the field.
- Retail limitations: Other grocery stores may only accept a certain size, color, or quantity, leaving farmers with extra product that doesn’t meet strict retail specs—but is still perfectly tasty and fresh.
Our mystery bundles help solve this by giving farmers flexibility. Instead of matching a rigid retail order, they can harvest and ship what’s freshest.
That’s a win for the farmer, for us (we prevent food waste!), and for the customer—who gets peak-season produce at a great price.
Ready to Discover New Farm Fresh Produce?
Each mystery bundle contains premium produce that has been harvested at peak freshness. Browse our organic grocery store delivery options now—including all of our latest mystery produce items—and enjoy the unexpected while helping to support farmers and reduce food waste.
Plus, it’s a great way to try new things! Not sure what to do with a shallot? We’ve got recipes. Never cooked with purple carrots before? We’ll show you how. Check out our recipe hub for tips on turning these organic grocery surprises into meals you love.
